Choose between our single pair Mystery Mailer subscription or the original two pair Plug Crate subscription.

Select your size and style. Our team curates your plugs based on your selected preference.

All subscriptions ship to your door monthly. No commitments. Cancel anytime.

Popular Questions

  • How many pairs do I get every month?

ThePlugCrate subscription box is 2 premium pairs per month. The Mystery Mailer and Large Size Mystery Mailer are 1 pair per month.

  • How much is shipping?

All subscriptions ship FREE within the continental U.S.A. Canadian and International subscriptions ship for a $6.99 fee.

  • What materials do you send?

Our subscriptions only include stone, wood, glass and 316L steel.

  • Can I change my size?

Absolutely! Stretching up is always exciting, and we can't wait to hook you up with cool new plugs. Simply visit your account management page to change your size and we'll take care of the rest.

  • When do subscriptions ship?

All subscriptions ship on the week of the 18th of every month with a cutoff of the 15th to be eligible for that months box.

  • Can I cancel?

While we don't think you'll ever want to cancel, we get it - sometimes you just need a break. You can cancel or pause your subscription at any time! No commitments.


Contact Us



11 a.m. - 6 p.m.

Monday - Friday


Social Connections