Mystery Mailer Subscription

Mystery Mailer Subscription

  • $17.99
  • Regular price $19.99

**All Subscriptions are auto-renewing until canceled. Renewals occur at regular price if purchased during a sale. Subscriptions ship the week of the 18th of every month. Orders must be placed by the 15th in order to qualify for that month's subscription. Unisex plugs are included in every subscription regardless of style option selected. Pre-Pay subscriptions cannot be purchased using Gift Cards. Please contact support to purchase a one month subscription using a Gift Card**

The little brother to the original Plug Crate. No frills, no hassle - receive ONE random pair of high-quality plugs or tunnels in a mystery mailer envelope every month. We only send you wood, stone, 316L Steel, or glass. Never silicone, and never acrylic. A great budget option for any plugger.

Customer Reviews

Based on 81 reviews
Daniel Stevens

Mystery Mailer Subscription

Bonnie Corbin

I love everything about plug crate in so happy with everything I have gotten love it 🥰💙💗

Sarah Ory
Perfect Pick

Absolutely loved both pairs that I received. I've gotten many compliments since wearing them! They are comfortable and quality materials. i cant wait to see what I receive next month

Dan Daniels
Worth the wait

I didn’t realize the date when I originally placed my order. So I had to wait which was no big deal. Let me tell you it was well worth the wait!! The stone plugs I received were excellent quality!! The best part is the ones I received weren’t what I normally would pick out for myself. Can’t wait until my next mailer shows up!!

Tracy Olsen
Exceptional product

I've been ordering gauges on amazon and other websites, and have gotten a variety of sizes. I've taken to using calipers to verify the gauges i order are correct, most of the junk from China is sized wrong and i return it. So far on the items received from plug crate they've all been spot on. Very happy with the products and I love the mystery box, always fun to get a suprise. The last box had a beautiful dragon scale black onyx plug set. I love it!