Large Size Mystery Mailer Subscription (Over 1")

Large Size Mystery Mailer Subscription (Over 1")

  • $22.99
  • Regular price $24.99

**All Subscriptions are auto-renewing until canceled. Renewals occur at regular price if purchased during a sale. Subscriptions ship the week of the 18th of every month. Orders must be placed by the 15th in order to qualify for that month's subscription. All plugs sent as part of the large size Mystery Mailer are unisex. Due to the handmade nature of organic plugs, there can be a size variance of up to 1mm on large sizes.**

Receive ONE random pair of high-quality plugs or tunnels in a mystery mailer envelope every month. We only send you wood, stone, 316L Steel, or glass. Never silicone, and never acrylic.


Customer Reviews

Based on 33 reviews
Sabrina Pence

I'm always so impressed with my monthly plugs. This month I received opal teardrops and they are absolutely stunning. I always recommend plugcrate because of the amazing prices & you can't go wrong with surprise plugs every month for a great deal!!


Never disappointed, although I would love for it to come with a tag stating what material it is! I received these brown/black spotted stone ones. I wish I just knew what kind of stone it was! Keep up the great work guys!

Michael Gibson
Beautiful tunnels

I've been wanting some opalite tunnels for a bit. Was stoked to see 1 1/4 inch opalites in my mystery box. I'm so stoked to see what comes this month.

Justin Lawyer
28 mm

Awesome plugs. Nice variety of stone and colors


Good quality, great price!