Mystery Mailer Subscription

Mystery Mailer Subscription

  • $17.99
  • Regular price $19.99

**All Subscriptions are auto-renewing until canceled. Renewals occur at regular price if purchased during a sale. Subscriptions ship the week of the 18th of every month. Orders must be placed by the 15th in order to qualify for that month's subscription. Unisex plugs are included in every subscription regardless of style option selected. Pre-Pay subscriptions cannot be purchased using Gift Cards. Please contact support to purchase a one month subscription using a Gift Card**

The little brother to the original Plug Crate. No frills, no hassle - receive 1 random pair of high-quality plugs or tunnels in a mystery mailer envelope every month. We only send you wood, stone, 316L Steel, or glass. Never silicone, and never acrylic. A great budget option for any plugger.

Customer Reviews

Based on 95 reviews
Michael Bryan
Unable to order

Not enough size options, I'm at 28mm and your sizing stops at 25mm so you're missing out on another customer.

Hey Michael

We have a Large Size Mystery Mailer subscription available for sizes over 1'. You can find the product here >>

Anthony Henriquez Moran

Great fit and style.

Wendy Neff
Happy happy

Beautiful! I've been ordering these for years. They are always on time and always fantastic! Thank you.


Amazing quality and customer service. I got the wrong size and they update my subscription and are sending me some new plugs. Great!

Kris Hunt
Mystery Plugs

I enjoying opening my mystery plugs every month. It’s fun to see what I get and the product is great!